Molly grew up in Silver Spring, Maryland, attending local Catholic schools. Before having children, Molly worked as an attorney in Washington, D.C., and Maryland. Once her children arrived, Molly stopped practicing law to focus on parenting. Molly and her husband, Eddie, joined the St. Raphael's community in 2017 when their oldest began kindergarten. Her two daughters, Phoebe and Roxanne, currently attend St. Raphael School. Since 2020, Molly has worked as a "recess mom" for the elementary school and a substitute in the nursery school. Molly lives in Gaithersburg with her husband, Eddie, and their daughters.